This essay Whether a passport can be revoked or not has been has a total of 746 words and 4 pages.
Whether a passport can be revoked or not has been a major question since the mid- 1800\'s. Haig v. Agee is a landmark Supreme Court case charging that the Secretary of State can not revoke a passport on the grounds that the power has never been granted by the Congress to the Secretary, and that revoking a passport violates the first and fifth amendments of the Constitution of the United States. Not only does the Secretary of State have implied powers, but revoking Agee\'s passport did not violate any laws or rights.
In Haig v. Agee, the defendant claims that the Passport Act of 1926 does not grant the Secretary of State the right to revoke passports. However, the Passport Act does state that the Secretary of State is the only person who can grant and withhold passport applications. And based upon later provisions, the Secretary can withhold applications if the party is involved with illegal activities. If the Secretary of State can grant and withhold passports, was it implied by the Congress that the Secretary has the powers to revoke passports?
"The Secretary of State may grant and issue passports, and cause passports to be granted, issued, and verified in foreign countries by diplomatic representatives of the United States . . . under such rules as the President shall designated and prescribe for and on behalf of the United States, and no other person shall grant, issue, or verify such passports." 22 U.S.C. 211a (1976 ed., Supp. IV).
Since the Congress did not specify who has the powers to revoke passports, it should be assumed that because the Secretary is the only person who can grant passports, they are the only ones who can revoke passports on grounds of illegal activities, such as treason. If you consider that Agee\'s passport was revoked because he was uncovering secret CIA agents, he was undoubtedly committing treason. Though treason is usually considered to be evident during times of war, treason can also be defined as placing national security in jeopardy, such as the case of Agee. Agee\'s passport should not only have been taken, he should have been extradited and tried by a jury for the crime of treason.
Agee also claims that since the power to revoke passports was not directly given to the Secretary of State or the President, then in order to show they have the power, they must have revoked many passports in the past and have the Congress\' approval. However, the need to revoke passports on the grounds of treason has not come up many times before; There is always a first and Agee might just have been it. The Congress did show approval when they voted to approve the President\'s provisions and amendments on the matter of revoking passports in 1978. This shows that the Congress agrees that the Executive branch has been recognized as having the power to revoke passports.
By revoking a passport, the government is not infringing on the party\'s first amendment rights, freedom of speech. The party involved is merely being told that they cannot leave the country, not that they cannot speak out against the government. For example, if a person is sentenced to jail, they cannot roam around the world, but they can speak out against the government. Revoking Agee\'s passport only limits where he can go, not what he can say; This does not infringe on any of his rights granted in the Constitution. Revoking a passport also does not infringe upon the fifth amendment because illegal activities are involved. For example, if you commit a crime, the police do not wait until after you go before a judge and/or jury before they put you in jail; They immediately incarcerate you as a precautionary move. Revoking a passport on grounds of national security does not require a hearing before hand because it is only a precautionary move.
Agee\'s grounds for suit are totally ludicrous. None of his rights have been violated, considering that he should have none because he is committing treason by revealing secrets of the United States and by compromising national security. Congress may not have said exactly who has the power to revoke passports, but they did mention that the Secretary of state is the only
Topics Related to Whether a passport can be revoked or not has been
Passports, Haig v. Agee, United States passport, Freedom of movement under United States law
Essays Related to Whether a passport can be revoked or not has been
GUN CONTROL OR NOT GUN CONTROL OR NOT? Imagine today, somebody or government came into your town and started taking possession of all your personal fire arms. Just so they could keep you under their control. What would you think or do about this? In the summer of 1768, the British army tried to disarm the new residents of Boston. This process went on until the end of 1775. This took place so that the King of England would not have his invincible army revolted against in the new land to the West. The bostonians of
Haig v Agee Power to Revoke PassportsHaig v. Agee: Power to Revoke Passports Whether a passport can be revoked or not has been a major question since the mid- 1800's. Haig v. Agee is a landmark Supreme Court case charging that the Secretary of State can not revoke a passport on the grounds that the power has never been granted by the Congress to the Secretary, and that revoking a passport violates the first and fifth amendments of the Constitution of the United States. Not only does the Secretary of State have implied powers, but r
Nuclear StrikesNuclear Strikes Scientifically, there is no obstacle for a nuclear or atomic bomb. There are no secrets in Nuclear Science anymore. Anyone with a reasonable physics degree and access to a good technical library could design a workable atomic bomb in less than 6 months, so why hasn't anyone. Maybe there has been, no one is exactly sure. In the last 52 years there has been enough nuclear warheads made to destroy every city in the world and still have thousands left over.(Church 40) This all happen
Vote No For Quebec To Be Separate From CanadaVote No For Quebec To Be Separate From Canada I urge you as a fellow Canadian to vote NO! to the upcoming referendum question. Canada as a whole has many unique qualities. Our most valued characteristic is our cultural diversity. Our combination of Anglophone and Francophone regions throughout our country and their ability to work together sets us apart from the rest of the world. Canada cannot function without Quebec just as Quebec cannot function without Canada. It has been said by many, that
The Reign of Terror The Reign of Terror History is said to be written by the winners, but is it possible to rewrite history? In a way, the French, like many who have preceded them, and many who will proceed them have done the impossible, rewriting history. From trivial folklore, such as George Washington chopping down a cherry tree, to the incredibly wrong, the African slave trade; people's views of history can be shaped and molded. The French have done a superb job of instilling all of us with the concept that th
Immigration-1Immigration The first immigrants to the territory now the United States were from Western Europe. The first great migration began early in the 19th century when large numbers of Europeans left their homelands to escape the economic hardships resulting from the transformation of industry by the factory system and the simultaneous shift from small-scale to large-scale farming. At the same time, conflict, political oppression, and religious persecution caused a great many Europeans to seek freedom
The first immigrants to the territory now the United States were from The first immigrants to the territory now the United States were from Western Europe. The first great migration began early in the 19th century when large numbers of Europeans left their homelands to escape the economic hardships resulting from the transformation of industry by the factory system and the simultaneous shift from small-scale to large-scale farming. At the same time, conflict, political oppression, and religious persecution caused a great many Europeans to seek freedom and securit
History is said to be written by the winners but is it possible to rew History is said to be written by the winners, but is it possible to rewrite history? In a way, the French, like many who have preceded them, and many who will proceed them have done the impossible, rewriting history. From trivial folklore, such as George Washington chopping down a cherry tree, to the incredibly wrong, the African slave trade; people’s views of history can be shaped and molded. The French have done a superb job of instilling all of us with the concept that their Revolution was a
Whether a passport can be revoked or not has been a major question sin Whether a passport can be revoked or not has been a major question since the mid- 1800's. Haig v. Agee is a landmark Supreme Court case charging that the Secretary of State can not revoke a passport on the grounds that the power has never been granted by the Congress to the Secretary, and that revoking a passport violates the first and fifth amendments of the Constitution of the United States. Not only does the Secretary of State have implied powers, but revoking Agee's passport did not violate
John Lennons AssassinationJohn Lennon’s Assassination Appendix 1 When I first started my research I decided to use an Internet source because it seemed like it would be very simple to find information on the Internet. After searching fro hours and not finding much information on the Internet I decided to go look at my packet at some websites that could help me, I went to www.google.com, and searched from there. I found some periodicals on a website and continued to search on different sites. I found some information abou
The Woman Warrior A story of a lost fightThe Woman Warrior. A story of a lost fight. English 455 Anger and confusion were following me as I was trying to fight my way through Maxine Hong Kingston’s masterpiece. I was helplessly looking for some answers. Who is the Woman Warrior? Where is the fine line between fiction and non-fiction, if there is one? What is the connection between all of the stories that seemed non-related to each other? And as soon as I thought that I figured it out, the author failed me again. I was surprised (and no
To what extent is the title Tzar Liberator a true description of AlexaTo what extent is the title “Tzar Liberator” a true description of Alexander II? “I am not handing over the command in the good order I should have wished, and I am bequeathing you much worry and distress” These were the words of Alexander’s father on his deathbed. The condition of the empire as it was handed down to Alexander II was pitiful; the autocratic system was flawed and neglected. The country’s national debts were continuously ascending and the economy was not going all too well eith
The July days nearly saw the Bolsheviks in ruins By October they had lThe July days nearly saw the Bolsheviks in ruins. By October they had launched a successful bid for power. How was this Possible? The provincial Government was a permanent form of power in Russia after the tsar was removed from power and would dissipate after the elections in November of the Constituent Assembly. This fact plays an important role in the shaping of Russia’s history. In March of 1917 the Petrograd soviets issue “Order Number 1” this is the first instance where we are able to see t
Terrorism and the International Court of Justice Terrorism and the International Court of Justice 04/26/01 PL SC 14H Terrorism and the International Court of Justice I. History of International Terrorism II. State Sponsored Terrorism A. Iran B. Sudan III. Benefits Derived From Terrorism A. Inexpensive and ability to advance ideologies B. Fear C. Publicity D. Minimal risk E. Lack of public defeat IV. Aspects of Terrorism A. Technological advances B. Weapons of mass destruction C. Cyber terrorism D. Suicide bombing V. Islamic Terrorist Organiza
The Hoa Lo Prison CampThe Hoa Lo Prison Camp During the Vietnam war many U.S. soldiers became prisoners of war (POWs). Some of those prisoners ended up in prisons such as the Hoa Lo prison. The Hoa Lo prison, located in the middle of the city of Hanoi, was nicknamed the Hanoi Hilton. It got this nickname because the building was formally the old Hotel Metropole. The prison was North Vietnam’s main penitentiary, and the Administrative headquarters for the country’s entire prison system. There were approximately one hu
A Farewell To Arms By Ernest Hemmingway A Farewell To Arms By: Ernest Hemmingway Plot Summary: Lieutenant Frederic Henry is a young American volunteer who is serving as an ambulance driver in the Italian army during WWI. It is the start of winter, and it has started raining. Henry has just returned from to the front from leave, and has learned that a major offense is about to start. Rinaldi his roommate / best friend has told him of a group of English nurses that have arrived and that he is in love with one of them, Catherine Barkley
Gandhi the movie a story of one man's devotion to his religion opened Gandhi the movie, a story of one man's devotion to his religion, opened a whole new aspect of the very different ways of the Hindu religion. The movie portrayed Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi as a man of courageous actions and strong will to pave the path for his people. Gandhi was ready and able to do anything and everything for his country. He stood up for the people by addressing the British government of the unfair justice that the people were living. Gandhi's way of non-violence, devotion and
Ernest Hemingway once gave some advice to his fellow writer F Scott Fi Ernest Hemingway once gave some advice to his fellow writer F. Scott Fitzgerald. If something in life hurts you, he said, you should use it in your writing. In A Farewell to Arms Hemingway followed his own advice. The painful experiences of his own life that, consciously and unconsciously, he placed in this novel help make it a major artistic achievement. The first of these experiences was a physical hurt that occurred on July 8, 1918. On this date, two weeks shy of his nineteenth birthday, H
Table of ContentsPage Table of Contents Page 1.Introduction 2 2.Central Reservation Systems 4 3.Global Distribution Systems 4 4.Internet Bookings 6 5.Conclusion 8 6.References 9 7.Bibliography 10 1.Introduction The last thirty years mankind has experienced a tremendous evolution in the technological field. On our way to the 21st century people have achieved innumerous things and all are based on the technological evolution which is applied in every aspect of the life; Telecommunications are improved, people can cont
What would you do if you were dying from an incurable disease and you What would you do if you were dying from an incurable disease, and you knew that you were going to suffer? Would you choose to go through all of the pain and suffering or would you look at other options, such as Euthanasia? Also known as Doctor Assisted-Suicide. People choose the way that they live, so they should be able to choose the way that they die. Why should someone else have the authority to force people to live in suffering or indignity if they don't want to? Some believe that Euthanas
Oliver NorthOliver North The United Sates of America had an embassy in Tehran. Tehran is the capital city of Iran. Iran is a country in the Middle East. It is bordered by, Iraq, Turkey, Kuwait, Afghanistan, and Pakistan. The Caspian Sea is to the North and the Persian Gulf is to the South West. In the 1970’s Iran was friendly with the United States. In autumn of 1979 the peace at the embassy stopped. There were student that would protest against the United States. Many of the students were taught in the Uni
ImmigrationImmigration Immigraton in the U.S. While immigration has played an important role in the building and formation of America, new federal laws have resulted in mass immigration. “America was primarily founded on immigrants, however, immigration must be controlled legally, and immigrants should be treated equally despite what country they come from. America has the most liberal laws towards immigrants than any other country.” Luis Barker, Chief Patrol Agent In-Charge, US Border Patrol, El Paso, TX.
The Roots of Judaism and ChristianityThe Roots of Judaism and Christianity (i) Judaism: The Jews are a people who trace their descent from the biblical Israelites and who are united by the religion called Judaism. They are not a race; Jewish identity is a mixture of ethnic, national, and religious elements. An individual may become part of the Jewish people by conversion to Judaism; but a born Jew who rejects Judaism or adopts another religion does not entirely lose his Jewish identity. In biblical times the Jews were divided into
Jimi HendrixJimi Hendrix James Marshal Hendrix was born on November 27th 1942, in Seatle Washington. He was considered by many to be the greatest guitarist to have ever lived. When he was 12 years old, his father traded his saxaphone to buy an inexpensive acoustic guitar for Jimmi. Though he never learned to read music, he tought himself by getting together with other local no-named bands and gigged for about 50 cents an hour and all the pop and food they could consume. When he was 17 he had his father sign
Campaign Finance IssuesCampaign Finance Issues GENERAL BACKGROUND INFORMATION We are not a democracy, yet we do have a voice in our own government. Elections are the choice microphones for many citizens. There on Election Day, they have the right of making their voices heard; however, many interest groups and a few individuals seem to have a louder voice due to campaign financing: No U.S. official should be beholden to one or a few groups. And no group or individual should have a greater claim on our elected leaders t
Iraq A Country on the RiseIraq: A Country on the Rise Lauterbach, Kevin History, Period 4 January 7, 1996 Iraq is a country that is on the rise. After being crushed by allied troops for their invasion of Kuwait, they have begun the slow rebuilding process. In this report, I will discuss the basic geographic features of Iraq, and other various important features such as mineral wealth, vegetation, ect. Iraq's total area is 271,128 square miles (just slightly more than twice the size of Idaho). It's capital, Baghdad, is lo
Terrorism As An International PhenomenonTerrorism As An International Phenomenon Terrorism as an International Phenomenon International terrorism, intelligence gathering and covert operations are all phenomenon, which intrigue the minds of many people both young and old. This paper is a historical recount and study on the various elements that comprise an international operation. It is also a vehicle for discussing the effects of intelligence agencies around the world, with particular interest in the CIA, Mossad, and KGB. This paper w
Immigration Problem with Too Many Immigrants in the USImmigration: Problem with Too Many Immigrants in the U.S Immigration is a major problem facing the U.S. today. Hundreds of thousands of immigrants flock to this country every year. Some legally, others illegally. Some are escaping from religious and political oppression while others come to seek out the American Dream. Either way they are causing nationwide problems. Non-English speaking workers take jobs away from American people because they will work for cheaper wages. Illegal immigrants re
Terrorism And The United StatesTerrorism And The United States Islamic Terrorism and The United States Michelle Gowka PLSC 14H 04/26/01 The Threat of Islamic Terrorism With the collapse of the Soviet Union in the early 1990's and the cold war over, the international community seemed to be on the threshold of an era of unprecedented peace and prosperity. Instead, a new series of problems was created, like ethnic conflicts, weapons proliferation, environmental problems, population growth, drug trafficking, and terrorism. Terror
Tell Me Lies by Jennifer Crusie Tell Me Lies by Jennifer Crusie Jennifer Crusie's Tell Me Lies deals with social problems like infidelity, domestic violence, divorce and the tragic consequences they have on the innocent children who are told nothing but lies even as their family crumbles around them. Crusie deftly touches on how people base their entire lives on nothing but lies that ultimately come down to nothing. The story begins in the most unexpected and unusual way, when Maddie Faraday finds a pair of black lace panti
Stereotypes and Identities Stereotypes and Identities Nowadays, social media has bonded cultures. Identities have been revealed to the world and thus stereotypes have been created. Stereotypes go back in history where people were characterized depending on their identities some as kings others as slaves â€¦. What makes up an identity? Many different understandings are present currently . S ome believe that identity is related to what country one was born in , others believe that it is determined by how many passports one