This essay Seguin i has a total of 1762 words and 9 pages.
Thesis statement: An international biosafety protocol should be created to establish and maintain control over the products designed with biotechnology.
I. The existing laws and regulations that govern the release of transgenic organisms are inadequate or nonexistent.
A. The developed nations of the world are using regulations that were designed to control and monitor crops created with traditional technologies.
B. Biotechnology is regulated by three different agencies.
C. The undeveloped nations have virtually no regulations governing transgenic organisms.
1. This indicates that biotechnological research can and is being conducted in these countries without regulation.
2. There are many biotech companies based in developed countries that have branches or joint ventures around the world.
II. The potential risks of transgenic organisms to the environment is still being determined.
A. Some experts warn that there is a danger that biotechnology can create mutant hybrids.
B. Biotechnology has the potential to harm the economies of some developing nations.
C. The last and possible the most important argument for an international biosafety protocol is in the name of ignorance and caution
III. The United States, Germany, Japan, and Australia are the only countries opposed to the biosafety protocol.
IV. The need for a change in the world of agriculture is undeniable.
Is there a need for one?
John M. Seguin
April 7, 1996
As the world moves closer to the 21st century, research and development in the area of biotechnology has increased dramatically. According to Bette Hileman of Chemical and Engineering News, the world population will increase by 3 billion people in the next thirty years while the amount of land available for agriculture cannot be greatly expanded. "Biotechnology - specifically that aspect involved in transferring genes from one species into the [DNA] of another - has the potential to alleviate . . ." (8) this and many other problems facing the world in the near future. Even though biotechnology has already shown dramatic results in the creation of beneficial transgenic (genetically engineered) species, many countries and researchers are ". . . quite leery about the uses of biotechnology" (8). Therefore, an international biosafety protocol should be created to establish and maintain control over the products designed with biotechnology.
The existing laws and regulations that govern the release of transgenic organisms are inadequate or nonexistent. In general, the developed nations of the world are using regulations that were designed to control and monitor crops created with traditional technologies like hybridization and cross-breeding (Hileman 8). Pamela Weintraub, of the National Audubon Society, states that many expected problems with biotechnology can be kept under control with proper regulations, but the regulations (where there are any) governing biotechnology today are "tangled and obscure" (164).
In the United States for example, biotechnology is regulated by three different agencies: the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA), the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). These three agencies regulate product research and commercialization of transgenic organisms depending upon their nature and intended use. The USDA regulates transgenic plants grown on a large scale. If a product of transgenic origin is to be used as a food, then it falls under FDA regulations. The EPA has jurisdiction over all transgenic organisms that express or function as a pesticide, and all genetically engineered microorganisms. Because Congress has elected not to instate a law specifically regulating transgenic organisms, all three of these agencies are using existing regulations designed for crops created by traditional methods. According to Bette Hileman of Chemical and Engineering News, "Under the existing legal framework, environmental releases of most genetically engineered animals are essentially unregulated" (9).
The undeveloped nations on the other hand have virtually no regulations governing transgenic organisms. This means that research can and is being conducted in these countries without regulation to protect the ecology. A resolution passed by the European Parliament confirmed this when they stated, "Deliberate releases of genetically modified organisms are being carried out in many developing countries, which have no legislation or infrastructure to ensure their safe use. . . "(Hileman 8). Further proof that this is taking place is the speed with which transgenic crops are being commercially produced in these nations. China, for example, has transgenic vegetables engineered for resistance to viruses that have been on the market for about 18 months. Similar transgenic crops in the United
The Positive And Negative Effects of DNA ProfilingThe Positive And Negative Effects of DNA Profiling Justin Broyles Apr. 12, 1995 Justice Theory Lance Miller Geneticengineering has developed and blossomed at a frightening rate in the last decade. Originating as merely an area of interest for scientists, geneticengineering has now become an area of which all people should be somewhat knowledgeable. DNA profiling has many uses, both positive and negative, in our society. Aside from its usefulness in many legal investigations, DNA profiling can
The Influence of Green Groups on the Policy of the United StatesThe Influence of Green Groups on the Policy of the United States Abstract: This research examines the relationship between environmental groups and the policies of the United States. The United States political system has been historically anthropocen-tric, or human centered. Environmental groups have been attempting to change this to a biocentric or ecocentric viewpoint, which includes the rights of animals and the environment. These views are nature centered instead of human centered. This stu
Title of Paper Theory of Evolution Title of Paper : Theory of Evolution Grade Received on Report : 87 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page INTRODUCTION ............................................... 2 DARWINIAN THEORY OF EVOLUTION .............................. 4 THE THEORY OF BIOLOGICAL EVOLUTION: CONTRIBUTING ELEMENTS ....................... 7 WALLACE'S CONTRIBUTIONS ................................... 13 HARDY-WEINBERG PRINCIPLE .................................. 15 COMPARISON: LAMARCK vs. DARWIN ........................... 16 DARWIN'S IN
The Human Genome ProjectThe Human Genome Project The Human Genome Project is a worldwide research effort with the goal of analyzing the structure of human DNA and determining the location of the estimated 100,000 human genes. The DNA of a set of model organisms will be studied to provide the information necessary for understanding the functioning of the human genome. The information gathered by the human genome project is expected to be the source book for biomedical science in the twenty-first century and will be of g
Clones 101clones 101 The rapid development of the technology for cloning has led to moral debates around the world on whether or not to ban creating human clones. With the advancement of clone technology two states, California and Michigan have already banned the cloning of humans. Everybody who thought it would proceed slowly and could be stopped was wrong, said Lee Silver, a professor from the University of Princeton (McFarling 1) . . . Without proper research on behalf of the politicians of Californi
Euthenasiaeuthenasia The Issue of Human Cloning The recent news of the successful cloning of an adult sheep-in which the sheep's DNA was inserted into an unfertilized sheep egg to produce a lamb with identical DNA-has generated an outpouring of ethical concerns. These concerns are not about Dolly, the now famous sheep, nor even about the considerable impact cloning may have on the animal breeding industry, but rather about the possibility of cloning humans. For the most part, however, the ethical concerns
The Issue of Human CloningThe Issue of Human Cloning The recent news of the successful cloning of an adult sheep-in which the sheep's DNA was inserted into an unfertilized sheep egg to produce a lamb with identical DNA-has generated an outpouring of ethical concerns. These concerns are not about Dolly, the now famous sheep, nor even about the considerable impact cloning may have on the animal breeding industry, but rather about the possibility of cloning humans. For the most part, however, the ethical concerns being rais
Cloning opens many doors of opportunities in the agricultural aspect o Cloning opens many doors of opportunities in the agricultural aspect of the United States of America. It has already been a major factor in saving the lives of many humans. I feel the society as a whole can not and should not degrade this scientifical finding. I feel that human cloning should not be done and that this subject raises too many ethical questions. I would like to focus on an agricultural aspect if I may. People raised hell when animal parts were put into humans to save lives and to
Seguin i Seguin i Outline Thesis statement: An international biosafety protocol should be created to establish and maintain control over the products designed with biotechnology. I. The existing laws and regulations that govern the release of transgenic organisms are inadequate or nonexistent. A. The developed nations of the world are using regulations that were designed to control and monitor crops created with traditional technologies. B. Biotechnology is regulated by three different agencies. C. The
Brave New World Essay Brave New World Essay By Aldous Huxley Prompt: Compare life as Huxley described it in the World State with life in the United States today. For more than half a century, science fiction writers have thrilled and challenged readers with visions of the future and future worlds. These authors offered an insight into what they expected man, society, and life to be like at some future time. A society can achieve stability only when everyone is happy, and the brave new world tries hard to ensure that
The rapid pace of technology and the advancement of scientific underst The rapid pace of technology and the advancement of scientific understanding in the past one hundred years are at the backbone for the distinctly twentieth century genre -- science fiction. Such rapid advancement in these fields of technology have opened up literally worlds of possibilities for the future. One hundred years ago the possibility of simply flying from city to city may have seemed nothing more than a distant futuristic dream to most. While a mere sixty years later the impossible wa
SHOULD CANADA BE ALLOWED TO CONTINUE WITH GENETIC ENGINEERING WITHOUT SHOULD CANADA BE ALLOWED TO CONTINUE WITH GENETICENGINEERING WITHOUT FEDERAL GUIDELINES? pg.1 Should Canada be allowed to continue with geneticengineering without federal guidelines? In the past ten years there has been a rise in a relatively new science, a science that raises alot of controversial questions with very few answers. This science is called GeneticEngineering. In it¹s simplest terms it is the reordering of a genetic DNA sequence. It is a very controversial science because it lea
The Success of Michael Crichton's Novels in the Media Industry The Success of Michael Crichton's Novels in the Media Industry One only has to look at the astonishing opening weekend of Paramount Pictures' action adventure thriller Congo which was universally panned by critics, to be reminded of the power of the person who created the underlying material: Jurassic Park author Michael Crichton. The film's whopping $24.6 million opening, which shocked insiders, underscored the value to Hollywood of an exclusive club of best-selling writers (Eller 3). Michael
The story Jurassic Park by Michael Crichton takes place on a small isl The story Jurassic Park, by Michael Crichton takes place on a small island near Costa Rica, it’s about a park full of dinosaurs created by Dr. Hammond. The dinosaurs are locked in large cages with electric fences. But as the mathematician Ian Malcolm predicted, nature cannot be controlled. They find this out when the security system goes out. They soon lost the electric fence and the dinosaurs started to escape. They try to restore the power and are successful but it did not matter since the di
Cloning Cloning Introduction: Have you ever wandered what it would be like to have a clone, or what it would be like have a twin? Well in a few years you might be able to clone yourself. That’s if they legalize it in the US I. What is cloning? Cloning is the scientific process of combining the DNA of one organism with the egg of another. Creating a perfect genetically matched lifeform. In other words getting an egg and fertilizing it. Then putting it back in the a surrogate mother. II. Who cloned Dolly
GENTIC ENGINEERING GENTIC ENGINEERING Abstract This paper sets out to defend human geneticengineering with a new bioethical approach, post-humanism, combined with a radical democratic political framework. Arguments for the restriction of human geneticengineering, and specifically germ-line enhancement, are reviewed. Arguments are divided into those which are fundamental matters of faith, or bio-Luddite arguments, and those which can be addressed through public policy, or gene-angst arguments. The four bio-L
Today we are more concerned with our environment than ever before Simi Today, we are more concerned with our environment than ever before. Similarly, it is my belief that we are more knowledgeable about our earth's environment than did previous generations. I do not believe it would be an understatement to say that the planet earth is in serious jeopardy--from the shrinking rain forests, to the polluting of the oceans and land, to the ozone layer problem. Nevertheless, for purposes of this discussion, it is my intent to focus on pesticides as one particularly ramp
The Morality of Genetic EngineeringThe Morality of GeneticEngineering In the novel Flowers For Algernon by Daniel Keyes, the main character, Charlie, is mentally handicapped and is given the chance to have is intelligence increased through geneticengineering. Charlie goes through with the operation and his intelligence quotient (IQ) is increased from 68 to 185, but by the end of the novel he is back to his old IQ of 68. I believe that geneticengineering should not be used to increase intelligence. Life is in God’s hands. He ha
James BondJames Bond The latest mission for James Bond is an action packed thriller that begins with an awesome high speed hover craft chase through a minefield in the demilitarized zone between North Korea and South Korea; and the action doesn't let up until we fade to black. James bond meets up with Jinx (Halle Berry) and Miranda Frost (Rosamund Pike) who play enticing roles in James' attempt to unmask a traitor and prevent an international catasrophe, World War. From Hong Kong to Cuba to London and Ice
Genetically Modified FoodGenetically Modified Food Science is a creature that continues to advance at a much higher rate than ever before. World of information adds to humans` discovery and smoothens the path for more advances. But never in history science will be able to deeply affect our lives as science of GeneticEngineering does. With all the respects to this new advancement, Biotechnology forces humanity's power over forces of nature and also carries the risks to human health, the environment, animal and biodivers
THE HUMAN GENOME PROJECT THE HUMAN GENOME PROJECT: Ethical or Unethical? ENGLISH 101 Monday, April 4, 2000. Cloning a human being is something that has been fantasized for a long time in science fiction. Until now, never in history has science been able to so deeply impact human lives, as geneticengineering will. The Human Genome Project, is an international effort to “map” the 3 billion parts of proteins that make up human deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA), is to be completed by the year 2003; the use of such technology po
The Process of Cloning and the Ethics InvolvedThe Process of Cloning and the Ethics Involved Cloning is a biomedical engineering process that has come into the national spotlight in recent months. In 1996, embryologists at the Roslin Institute near Edinburgh, Scotland amazed scientists around the world as they were the first to successfully produce a clone using a specialized cell from an adult vertebrate. Although it is considered a biological breakthrough, the event has produced controversy over the ethics of the process. Cloning is a pro
Genetically modified organisms have no place outside the laboratoryGenetically modified organisms have no place outside the laboratory Genetic modification is the modification of genetic modification of genetic make-up so that modification is passes on to the organism’s descendants. Recently the term has come to be used for the process of ‘geneticengineering’ where newly developed processes of molecular biotechnology are used to insert relatively few genes into an organism’s genome. These techniques rely on the ability to cut DNA precisely, isolate desired fra
Genetic Engineering HistoryGeneticEngineering History You would think that GeneticEngineering began recently, but it dates back to the 1800's with Charles Darwin’ s Theory of Evolution. His theory includes the five points of natural selection: 1. Variation in Populations Many variations are inherited from parents to their offspring. 2. Some Variations are Favorable Variations are favorable when they improve the organism's ability to function and reproduce in its own particular environment. 3. More Offspring than can Su
VirusVirus A scientist funded by the US government has deliberately created an extremely deadly form of mousepox, a relative of the smallpox virus, through geneticengineering. The new virus kills all mice even if they have been given antiviral drugs as well as a vaccine that would normally protect them. The work has not stopped there. The cowpox virus, which infects a range of animals including humans, has been genetically altered in a similar way. The new virus, which is about to be tested on anima
Genetically Modified Foods to Eat or not to eatGenetically Modified Foods: to Eat or not to eat Abstract Genetically modified (GM) foods have been around for quite some time. Chances are, just about everyone has eaten some type of GM food product. With the new and developing technologies that the biotechnology industry has to offer, the GM food market has risen in leaps and bounds. A genetically modified food is a food that has had its genetic make-up altered in some way by DNA technology. It can involve the transfer of genes from one organi
Hydrothermal Vents- ecosystems below the seaHydrothermal Vents- ecosystems below the sea The hydrothermal vents are essentially geysers on the sea floor that support unusual chemical based ecosystems. Some scientists think that vents are the origin environments where life began on Earth billions of years ago. And the vents might also hold clues to life on other planets. This ecosystem may be one of the most ancient of Earth and have had a long-term effect on global geochemical cycles, however it is one of the least well understood. Hydrot
Is Modern Medicine A Threat To The Human Gene PoolIs Modern Medicine A Threat To The Human Gene Pool? The human gene pool is the source of diversity between us. It is this that attributes to the 0.1% difference in DNA between you and the next person (Cohen, 2001). Competition, starvation, predators and disease among others acted as selective pressures on our ancestors and thereby pushed and pulled the gene pool in different directions. Overall, those with genes that suited the environment survived and reproduced, while those with less suited ge
Chapter 11Chapter 11 Journal 4 2/22/04 o 4. (a) This is true, as stated in the textbook, “Any synthetic or natural chemical can be harmful if ingested in a large quantity.” Also some chemicals that are not toxic can be more dangerous then toxic chemicals. It all matters on the chemical concentration and on the amount of detection are found. (b) This statement is true in some part, small dosages or small exposures to toxic chemicals we should not worry about because our body can genetically adapt and clear
Australian Environmental Policy MakingAustralian Environmental Policy Making Reading Analysis Wk 3 This article aims to discuss the evolution of environmental politics thus far, as well predict its trend for the future. It begins by informing the reader of the development of environmental values and how they have emerged and have been shaped by democracy. It draws together environmental values and other important values which are social justice (equity), economic prosperity, national security and democracy. Given that every part of
Construction Design and Analysis of a Single-lesion Containing ShuttleConstruction, Design and Analysis of a Single-lesion Containing Shuttle Vector for Use in Studies of Transcription-coupled DNA Repair This summer, I have had the incredible opportunity of working with ___ under the direct mentorship of ___ on designing, constructing and analyzing a single-lesion containing shuttle vector to be used for studies of transcription-coupled DNA repair (TCR). This experience has provided me with insight into the logic behind geneticengineering and experiment design an
What are the limits of Genetic EngineeringWhat are the limits of GeneticEngineering? 3rd Quarter Seminar 25 March 2004 What is geneticengineering? Geneticengineering is the alteration of an organism's DNA, or genetic, material to eliminate undesirable characteristics or to produce desirable new ones. The most controversial form of geneticengineering, by far, is cloning. Cloning is another technology that has evolved out of genetic research. While geneticengineering usually adds or removes just one or two genes, cloning involves rep
Writing piece 1 ArgumentativeInformative essay on Human Genetic EngineWriting piece 1 – Argumentative/Informative essay on Human GeneticEngineering Statement of Intention: Geneticengineering is a process where human scientists tamper with the genetic code of un-born babies, thus being able to manipulate the genes and shape the baby into whatever they want by taking out certain genes. In this essay, we’ll have a look as to why Geneticengineering isn’t good for our society. Though some parents might agree to have their babies genetically engineered, there is a gr
Australian ExportsAustralian Exports Australia exports $120m of animals to different countries which involves terrible consequences to the animals, such as diseases, animal cruelty and the usage of hormones. On the other hand thanks to the management of the livestock exportation Australia’s economy is larger and more powerful comparing to other countries, this helps with the good relations with different countries and also Australia covers the largest beef industry in the world. The Australian beef industry is ev
Genetically Modified FoodGenetically Modified Food Table of contents Topic Page Abstract 2 Health 3-4 Environment 5-7 Farming 8-9 Economic 10 Thought of scientist 11-12 Conclusion 13 Reference 14 –15 Appendix 16 Abstract Genetically modified food or GM food is firstly introduced to the world since 1997 to 1999. GM foods are the product of mixing several genes into another food such as corn and tomato. Even though mixing gene will allow the food to grow faster but it may causes lots of harmful effects. This report will s
Human Cloning is WrongHuman Cloning is Wrong I bet many of you have seen Star Wars, Jurassic Park, Multiplicity, or many of the other movies that describe cloning. Most of what you see in these movies is false. What you don't know if that cloning could be dangerous, to the clone and to our society as a whole. It's unethical to have a human clone. What about identity? Humans are guaranteed the right to their own personality. What would happen if we overrode those rights by giving them someone else's genetic identity?
GeneticGeneticEngineering For many years, man has been advancing his race through technology. Many things through those were questionable and questionable, but none are close to a certain technology today. And that would be geneticengineering. What exactly is geneticengineering? To put it shortly, it is where scientists splice, alter, and manipulate genes of one thing to how the scientist want it, and even insert that gene into a foreign host. This technological tool is too powerful for us to handl
Task Do the advantages outweigh the disadvantages of genetic engineeriTask: Do the advantages outweigh the disadvantages of geneticengineering with specific reference to GENERAL STUDIES Task: Do the advantages outweigh the disadvantages of geneticengineering with specific reference to Gattaca? Gattaca, a film, takes place in the near future, in a time when geneticengineering technology is used is used to create a perfect society. Gatttacaï¿½s main character, Vincent, is genetically inferior; he was conceived by natural birth, rather than genetically engineered,
Cloning What is it and what is a clone Simply stated a clone is a dupl Cloning? What is it and what is a clone? Simply stated, a clone is a duplicate-- much like a photocopy is a duplicate, or copy, of a document. A good example of such copies that occur in nature are identical twins, which are duplicates of each other. On a daily basis, molecular geneticists and other scientists use cloning techniques to replicate various genetic materials such as gene segments and cells. In light of this relatively new science, many questions come to mind. How will those appli
Genetic engineering one of the most recent technologicalGeneticengineering, one of the most recent technological sciences, is now a great issue in society. While the effects of it can be very helpful in some ways, it can also cause many problems. In spite of potential risks, geneticengineering should be allowed in some fields of science. Collier's Encyclopedia defines geneticengineering as recombinant DNA technology, the application of biochemical and genetic techniques to alter the chromosomal materials, the basic genetic substance of cells (Ko
CLONINGCLONING Geneticengineering, altering the inherited characteristics of an organism in a predetermined way, by introducing into it a piece of the genetic material of another organism. Geneticengineering offers the hope of cures for many inherited diseases, once the problem of low efficiencies of effective transfer of genetic material is overcome. Another development has been the refinement of the technique called cloning, which produces large numbers of genetically identical individuals by trans
1996-1997 1996-1997: A Momentous Year in Science The scientific event that probably got the most attention and media coverage this year was the cloning of an adult sheep, Dolly. The fact that this event got so much attention is indicative of the change and broadening of the ethical debates surrounding geneticengineering. Not only is the bioethical controversy surrounding geneticengineering becoming a more popular subject, it is, thanks in large part to Dolly, becoming a more real and pressing matter. C
Genetic Engineering 97GeneticEngineering, 97 INTRODUCTION In 1953, Francis Crick and James Watson discovered the structure of DNA and opened up a new world of genetic experimentation. Today, 44 years later, biologists are working on projects that might provide possible cures for many genetic diseases. This field, called GeneticEngineering, is becoming a household word even with those segments of our population that are not scientifically oriented. Geneticengineering refers to a number of different techniques that
The topic of my research paper is Gene Therapy Gene Therapy is findingThe topic of my research paper is Gene Therapy. Gene Therapy is finding flawed genes, and then replacing the bad genes with good genes to better help a person. There are different ways to set off genes. For example, an environmental factor could trigger a flawed gene or it could be in your family's lineage, which would make it hereditary, 'The Genetic Revolution will change medicine more in the next 20 years than it has changed it in the past 2,000 years.' (Hood 779). Anyways, both, when set o
Brave New World 1932 is one of the most insidious works of literature Brave New World (1932) is one of the most insidious works of literature ever written. An exaggeration? Tragically, no. Brave New World has come to serve as the false symbol for any regime of universal happiness. So how does Huxley turn a future where we're all notionally happy into the archetypal dystopia? If it's technically feasible, what's wrong with using biotechnology to get rid of mental pain altogether? Brave New World is an unsettling, loveless and even sinister place. This is because H
Every spring there is a plethora of new animate beings Creation is a y Every spring there is a plethora of new animate beings. Creation is a yearly event for most animals. There are countless children born each day. All living beings procreate. Victor Frankenstein was a scientist, and the goal of science is to discover new information, and Victor Frankenstein was simply being a scientist and creating new information. When Victor Frankenstein created his monster, it could be compared to geneticengineering or cloning of today. Scientists are trying to re-create lif
Correcting the Code Correcting the Code Often there is a sudden breakthrough in a field of sciences, a key moment, an experiment, an event that changes people’s lives all over the world. In September of 1990, the first genetic treatment of a human being with an inherited illness was they key moment or event for genetics. They injection of a genetically altered white blood cells into the child’s body was little more than a transfusion. The child sat on a bed, an intravenous tube was hooked to her arm and her own wh
One can imagine lying in bed with the knowledge that they have only a One can imagine lying in bed with the knowledge that they have only a week to live. This prognosis is brought on because the person needs a new heart, liver, kidney, or any other life saving organ. Now that the realization of what has transpired hits this person it is time to find an organ donor. It could be the next car crash victim or someone from the immediate family. However, the odds of finding a donor grim. Wouldn't it be nice if the technology to clone a perfectly matching organ to repla
Using Characters as a Study in Human Nature Using Characters as a Study in Human Nature Authors use their characters to both tell the story as well as to symbolize different aspects of human nature. Although it is easy to determine a person's character in a work of non-fiction, it is more difficult to analyze the character of human nature in a fiction book, particularly when the author's characters are deep and multi-dimensional. In George Orwell's 1984, there are several main characters that show the many sides of a human being's charac
BRAVE NEW SOMETHING BRAVE NEW SOMETHING A doctor closes the door behind him and moves to sit down at his desk. The young couple waits nervously to hear the results. The doctor folds his hands and tells the expecting parents, “Your child will be born with Downs’ Syndrome, an IQ of 72, and no matter what he does, he will always have trouble keeping his weight down.” The couple winces in disappointment. “But”, says the doctor, “There is a process by which we can change all that for the better”. The process is called