How can a Native minority hold on to their heritage when they are thru
This essay How can a Native minority hold on to their heritage when they are thru has a total of 1095 words and 4 pages.
How can a Native minority hold on to their heritage when they are thrust into a majority white society, ignorant to their values? The author of Green Grass Running Water, Thomas King, examines this question is his eye-opening novel. By the cleaver way he sculpts his novel and the unique plot lines, he seems to leave the answer to the readers interpretation. Consequently, I found it a struggle to come up with any concrete answer. Maybe because their isn’t one, and if there is I am not the most qualified person to pass judgment. I have never had to compromise my culture, because I am part of the cultural mainstream. I am an English speaking, American born, white male with very loose ties to my Jewish faith, thus I have had to adjust very little to function successfully in society. Because of this, the best I can do is “attempt” to identify with the Native characters in G.G.R.W. Also an analysis of the term “success” is important before reaching any conclusions. What is Thomas King trying to say?
Some of the material in the novel sways towards the side that a Native can’t be successful(by white standards) without seriously compromising their minority culture. In the plot line involving Charlie Looking Bear and his father Portland this argument is supported. Charlie is the Blackfoot Indian that is hired right out of law school to represent Duplessis International Associates. Duplessis is attempting to continue construction of a dam on an Indian reserve. From this comfortable case, Charlie becomes wealthy enough to buy extravagant luxuries, like a red Porche. He is by many standards, successful. The evident problem with his method of success is that he achieved success by fighting against his own tribe. To further this notion, take a look at the story of Charlie’s father, Portland. Wanting to be an actor, Portland goes to Hollywood(first time). He is fully aware that the only acting jobs he can get are in Western movies. He usually attracts roles where he plays the token stereotypical Indian, the “scalping savage” who without a doubt gets killed by the end of the movie. He seems to have lost his Native identity. He has to move away from the reserve, away from his peoples, to travel to Hollywood in order to become successful. Furthermore, he has to propagate the stereotype of Indian people (i.e. wearing the fake nose), prolonging societies ignorance of real Native culture. In both Charlie and Portland’s situation, not only do they have to personally sacrifice their culture to get the success they desire, but they also have to indict the already struggling Native lifestyle as a whole.
On the contrary side of the argument, “success” is a very ambiguous term. No all-encompassing definition of success exists. Therefore, it would be naive to say that all cultures have the same out-look on success. The Capitalism of the United States and to a lesser extent Canada, leads me to believe that the white North American concept of success is based purely on money. I agree that it is wrong to judge the success of the Native characters in the novel solely by this standard. If you look at the character Eli, who is by no means monetarily rich, he could in some ways, be considered successful. He went to university; he has the qualifications to become a successful member of the majority society (university professor), yet he decides to live on the reserve. He made a discission based on his cultural values not on the values imposed on him by the majority white society. He was successful in his own mind because he was doing what he wanted. In his mind he wasn’t giving up much, if anything at all. As well, the entire situation with Portland isn’t as simple as it seems either. Maybe it is possible to achieve success and keep you culture after all? At the end of the novel when he become a celebrity for the second time, it is in a more culturally respective fashion. He no longer wears the ridiculous plastic nose, and is a celebrity in a society that allows westerns movies to have endings where the Natives win (thanks to the four Indian elders). On the other
Topics Related to How can a Native minority hold on to their heritage when they are thru
Demography, Immigration, Population, Canadians, Culture of Canada, American culture, Cultural studies, Melting pot
Essays Related to How can a Native minority hold on to their heritage when they are thru
Why Do Governments Find It So Hard To Control Public ExpenditureWhy Do Governments Find It So Hard To Control Public Expenditure? Since the 1970's rising public expenditure has become a politically salient issue, with the focus being on the difficulties experienced in trying to control it. In order to answer a question concerning why governments find it hard to control public expenditure it is first necessary to look at the reasons for the growth in public spending. There are three approaches which attempt to give reasons for growing public expenditure which
Cultural Diversity in Local PoliticsCultural Diversity in Local Politics Overview This paper explores the limits and potentials of ethnic and racial coalition building in Los Angeles. The demographic changes that have occurred in Los Angeles during the past twenty years have been extraordinary, both in scope and diversity. The area has witnessed a literal boom in population growth, increasing from 7 million in 1970 to 8.8 million in 1990. (US Bureau of the Census) However, it is the dramatic change in ethnic and racial diversity o
1 Explain and evaluate critically Malthuss population theory 1. Explain and evaluate critically Malthus’s population theory. In 1798 Thomas Robert Malthus, a British clergyman and professor, wrote an essay showing the way to modern demography. In 1824 he wrote a shorter final version, the article on population for that year’s Encyclopedia Britannica. Malthus has been criticized for his lack of scientific foresight—he did not foresee modern advances leading to increased life expectancy, food production and birth control. He has been criticized for his pol
Business plays a major role within our society It is a creative and co Business plays a major role within our society. It is a creative and competitive activity that continuously contributes to the shaping of our society. By satisfying the needs and wants people cannot satisfy themselves, businesses improve the quality of life for people and create a higher standard of living. It is a way for individuals to provide goods and services to consumers, and at the same time, produce a profit for themselves. Businesses are not only important because they provide goods an
Apollo Hospitals India Apollo Hospitals, India Considering the elements of a strategic service vision, the following are the factors applicable to the Apollo Hospitals of India. The service vision framework are according to an exhibit from Lessons in the Service Sector by James L. Heskett, Harvard Business Review, March/April 1987, p. 120. 1. Target Market segments · Population Statistics : Population above 920 mill. people with wide variety of economic levels, social statuses, and cultures. Lowest per capita GNP $
Professional historians spend their lives pursuing the meaning of the Professional historians spend their lives pursuing the meaning of the past for the present. Everything that exists in today’s world has some origin coming from the past. Everything that exists today and seems to be unique of its time has some basis from the past. It is a known fact that history has a tendency of repeating itself, and so to prepare us for the future we need to understand the past. History can give a person an answer to almost everything that is going on in the present, with wh
MEXICO MEXICO Southward from its 1,500 mile long border with the United States lies the Estados Unidos Mexicanos. A country with slightly more than 750,000 square miles in area, Mexico has a vast array of mineral resources, limited agricultural land, and a rapidly growing population. These factors are the basis for many of the country's present problems as well as opportunities for future development. The nation is struggling to modernize its economy. With more than 80 million people in the mid-1980s,
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION Business plays a major role within our society. It is a creative and competitive activity that continuously contributes to the shaping of our society. By satisfying the needs and wants people cannot satisfy themselves, businesses improve the quality of life for people. It is a way for individuals to provide goods and services to consumers, and at the same time, produce a profit for themselves. Businesses are not only important because they provide goods and services for
The District is the exclusive local agency within the South Coast Air The District is the exclusive local agency within the South Coast Air Basin with responsibility for comprehensive control of air pollution from all sources other than emissions from motor vehicles. The District is one of several multi-county agencies in California where the geography and demography combine to make local control of air pollution most practical on a regional basis. The South Coast Air Basin generally comprises those natural geopgrphical areas where air quality is influenced by em
Another BrazilAnother Brazil Brazil: National Context Geography Brazil occupies almost one-half of the entire South America continent, and is the fifth largest country in the world. It borders all Latin American countries except Chile and Ecuador. The 9,170km coastline and the 50,000km navigable inland waterways provide great potentials for water transportation which has not been well developed. Brazil is topographically relatively flat. 40% of the land is under the Amazon Rain Forest. Most of the arable land