This essay Essay Politics 1A has a total of 1883 words and 13 pages.
Essay Politics 1A
Is it of any consequence that Non Departmental Bodies (‘Quango’s) lack democratic accountability?
In order to understand the accountability of Quangos we must first understand what they truly are and then from their definition we can progress to examine whether or not they can be and should be held accountable by the people whose money they spend, the taxpayer themselves.
“The world of the Quango is inhabited by organisations referred to by political scientists as many things including to name a few, ‘fringe bodies’, ‘non- departmental organisation….. ‘semi-autonomous authorities’ and ‘quangos’”. (British politics 3rd edition coxall & robins pg 333) As can be seen by the above definition and also the contents of the chapter referring to quangos in most part, in any book that can be referred to, the definitions for quangos are varied, different and in most part very confusing.
The word quango was coined to describe \'quasi autonomous non-governmental organisations\'. Quangos spend taxpayers\' money, are ultimately responsible to central government and are unelected. They can be local or national bodies can be advisory bodies or be responsible for delivering services. They operate at arms length from government and therefore are more independent of central government than, for example, civil servants. However, there is widespread disagreement about exactly which organisations can be classed as quangos. According to the government the number of quangos has gone down since 1979. But according to others the number has risen quite dramatically (See table 1.1). Whatever the case, quangos have become one of the main issues in the debate about democracy. “there is an executive quango for every 10,000 people in the U.K” (Hall and Weir 1996)
(British politics 3rd edition coxall & robins)
The Democratic Audit’s 1996 Quango count
No of Quangos
Non departmental/executive quangos
Local executive quangos
Career Service Companies
City Technology Colleges
Further education Corporate bodies
Grant maintained Schools
Higher education Corporations
Local Enterprise Companies
Training and Enterprise Councils
The total Quango Count
The existence of quangos is undeniable, but of course it is those who sit on the bodies themselves that make up the complexion of the certain quango and therefore contribute to decision making powers that ultimately effect people. But who are these people and how do they acquire these positions of “power”?
Democratic Audit claims that 65,419 people currently sit on quangos. They are mostly appointed by the relevant Minister or by someone else he or she has appointed. The procedure and criteria for selecting and appointing people to quangos are secret. There is a list of candidates, held by the Public Appointments Unit, which is also secret. Once appointed, the government does release names and brief details of career, but it does not as a matter of course publish other information and does not, for example, say what if any the appointees\' political affiliations are.
There is some concern that a disproportionate number of quango appointees have had links with the Conservative party. For example Baroness Denton, when a DTI minister in charge of making many quango appointments, said she had \'never knowingly appointed a Labour supporter.\' A recent study discovered that 62 of the 185 NHS Trust chairmen, including three former Tory MPs, had clear links with the Conservative party. However, the Nolan Committee has recommended that Ministers should not be completely free to make these decisions: a commissioner should be appointed to check that \'suitable\' and experienced people are appointed and that jobs are not handed out for political purposes.
Already we can see the concern of lack of accountability building up slowly towards the quango system. What is a Quango? Many argue they lack definition and also why so much secrecy surrounds the appointment and role of people sitting on the respective quangos? But many other concerns are also entailed.
Concerns about local quangos have been expressed in two areas. Firstly there has been the change caused to the balance between central and local government, given that the quangos are in general ultimately accountable to central government. Doubts have been raised about the adequacy of central accountability: the doctrine of ministerial responsibility in a modern department stretches credibility. In addition the line of accountability from a local quango to the minister can be long and indirect. Furthermore there is a powerful argument for making bodies which determine local
Topics Related to Essay Politics 1A
Political terminology, Quango, Accountability, Non-departmental public body
Essays Related to Essay Politics 1A
Pornography Debate Pornography Debate Suppose one accepts MacKinnon and Dworkin's suggested statutory definition of pornography. How does one who generally accepts MacKinnon and Dworkin's views on the pervasively harmful effect of pornography, and who accepts a need for legal redress of the harms perpetrated by pornography, deal with pornographic material? The ordinance proposed by MacKinnon and Dworkin would deal with such material by enacting legislation which gives people adversely affected by the works, which
Pierre Trudeau former Prime Minister of Canada was once described as Pierre Trudeau, former Prime Minister of Canada, was once described as A French Canadian proud of his identity and culture, yet a biting critic of French-Canadian society, determined to destroy its mythology and illusions. He has also been identified as A staunch, upholder of provincial autonomy holding the justice portfolio in the federal government. Such cumulative appraisal and observation made by past fellow bureaucrat provides high testimonial for the ex-Democratic Socialist. This crit
A Case of Needing Serious Revisions A Case of Needing Serious Revisions Michael Crichton has penned some of the most engaging, timely, and thoroughly accessible tales to be published in the last twenty-five years. What his novels lack in literary merit and distinctive style they make up for in crisp plotting and edge-of-your-seat suspense. From alien viruses to regenerated dinosaurs, from evil Japanese monoliths to the insidious maneuverings of the modern corporation, Crichton latches onto the scientific and political controversi
Odds on - creating and maintaining a national art collection in South Odds on - creating and maintaining a national art collection in South Africa The mainstay of any museum is its permanent collection. The story of the initiators and major benefactors of the South African National Gallery (SANG) is a significant one which cannot be told here, but which all the same has to be mentioned and acknowledged. The first efforts towards the formation of an art gallery in Cape Town were made in 1871 by the South African Fine Arts Association, and were given further impetus
PoliticsPolitics The ideologies of politics or politics itself could be viewed either positively or negatively depends on which aspect of politics people look at. It is not an exaggeration to say that it is hard to define politics, for it covers such a comprehensive areas of our world. ‘Politics concerns the behaviour of groups and individuals in matters that are likely to affect the course of government.’ (Raphael, 1970: 27) When people look back at ancient times when people work during the day times a
Media coverage of football hooliganismMedia coverage of football hooliganism Football hooliganism can be seen as something of an easy target' for the media. With journalists present at every match across the country, the chances of a story being missed are slim. TV cameras also mean that disturbances within stadiums are caught on video. Since the 1960s, in fact, journalists have been sent to football matches to report on crowd behaviour, rather than just the game 1. The British tabloid press in particular have an enthusiastic' appro
Thesis Government Censorship would damage the atmosphere of the freedoThesis: Government Censorship would damage the atmosphere of the freedom to express ideas on the Internet; therefore, government should not encourage censorship. Introduction I. In the Internet community, there is a large volume of technical terms. For this reason, it is first necessary to examine the terminology specific to Internet. 1.The internet is a world wide computer network. 1.Electronic mail (email), which is one component of the Internet, approximates person to person letters, memorand
BOOK REVIEWBOOK REVIEW Scientific racism claims that biological inheritance determines the character and behavior of social groups we identify as races. Despite its history of oppression and genocide, the scientific defense of racial inequality demonstrates a disturbing persistence. Murphy Ballen’s study of scientific racism in Great Britain and the United States in the 1920s and 1930s appropriately deals not with its demise but with its retreat. Making extensive use of private correspondence, Ballen relat
Throughout American history each generation has sought to individualiz Throughout American history, each generation has sought to individualize itself from all others preceding it. Decades of American history can be separated to represent a distinctive set of values, culture, and political ideals. The 1960's was a decade caught between euphoric, idealistic beginnings and a discordant, violent climax. The music of this time period produced a strong counterculture which sought to influence America in a way never before experienced. The songs were the backbone of thi
An Army A Navy and Ebonics An Army, A Navy, and Ebonics CONTENTS 1. Introduction 2. The Ebonics controversy 2.1 Declaration of a separate language 2.2 Bilingual education funding 2.3 Classroom teaching and Ebonics 2.4 Summary and comment 3. Afro-American languages and dialects 3.1 Black English: the creolist position 3.2 Black English: the dialectologist position 3.3 Toward a synthesis 3.4 On the issue of African influence 3.5 Summary and comment 4. Language, identity, and politics 4.1 Obtaining linguistic recognition 4.
Another TrudeauAnother Trudeau Pierre Trudeau, former Prime Minister of Canada, was once described as A French Canadian proud of his identity and culture, yet a biting critic of French-Canadian society, determined to destroy its mythology and illusions . He has also been identified as A staunch, upholder of provincial autonomy holding the justice portfolio in the federal government . Such cumulative appraisal and observation made by past fellow bureaucrat provides high testimonial for the ex-Democratic Sociali
Modernism And CinderellaModernism And Cinderella April 25, 2000 Research Writing Though there are many fairy tales that have been created through the years, Cinderella is into our subconscious by stimulating the part of us that sympathizes with the mistreatment of Cinderella. Others say that the theme of a down-and-out poor girl rising up to become rich and happy appeals to any normal person. This theme is the common bond between all the stories. Recently, however, modern versions of the tale have surfaced in an attemp
A Analysis Of Jack London NovelsA Analysis Of Jack London Novels A literary Analysis of Jack London three most recognized works, Sea Wolf; The Call of the Wild; and White Fang. Jack London lived a full life, even though he died at the young age of forty. In his life time he experienced many things, and I believe that these experiences were the catalyst of his novels. Jack London was an oyster pirate, a government patrolman in San Francisco Bay, a sailor and an agrarian reformer, a seal hunter in the North Pacific and a gold pr
PornoPorno Suppose one accepts MacKinnon and Dworkin's suggested statutory definition of pornography. How does one who generally accepts MacKinnon and Dworkin's views on the pervasively harmful effect of pornography, and who accepts a need for legal redress of the harms perpetrated by pornography, deal with pornographic material? The ordinance proposed by MacKinnon and Dworkin would deal with such material by enacting legislation which gives people adversely affected by the works, which clearly fit t
Time for Americans To Be A FamilyTime for Americans To Be A Family By D.C. Burch It seems to be a time for Americans to try and be a family again. Maybe a quarrelsome and restless family not entirely happy with each member all of the time, but a family nonetheless. OK, I admit it. I am confused and perplexed by the storm of political correctness sweeping throughout the nation, raising dust-devils and tempests; leaving destruction and chaos in its wake. The English language is being transmogrified to quell and satisfy members of
Falun GongFalun Gong expense of the health system to many people and faltering mutual support networks, the positive effects of Qigong practice and the support networks resulting from membership will have been supportive for the spread of the Falun Gong. However, the Falun Dafa is taught as a path which is more than just the practice of Qigong; is seen a way of life. 1 Founder Li Hongzhi (a.k.a. Master Li) has said that, in the past, its secrets were passed only from master to student. Hongzhi made the mo
Correctly Political A Look into the Dynamics of Political CorrectnessCorrectly Political: A Look into the Dynamics of Political Correctness Every American probably knows what it means to be politically correct. After all, we hear about it on the news almost every night. We have to be constantly aware of whether or not something we say or do is going to offend someone. This mode of communication is present in every aspect of our lives, from the most formal to the most informal situations. This paper will answer questions on the origin of the term ‘politically corr
Revolution Girl-style NowRevolution Girl-style Now! Revolution Girl-Style Now! Riot Grrrls were originally born out of the â€śPunkâ€ť scene where rebellion was expressed in attitude, appearance, style, and music. Defining Riot Grrrl is much like defining Punk. There is no central organization, no authoritive definition, just an attitude concerned with pointing out social hypocrisy and empowering people to â€śdo it yourselfâ€ť, creating a culture of their own when they see that the mainstream media does not reflect their
Strange weather in King Lear CRITICISM Strange weather in King Lear Steve Mentz* St John’s University, New York, USA This article argues that King Lear can help re-shape the emerging discourse of eco-criticism. The play’s focus on human dis-harmony with the non-human environment resonates with recent developments in ecological science like the ‘‘post-equilibrium shift’’. Shakespeare’s representations of dis-equilibrium in the storm scenes can correct eco-criticism’s reliance on pastoral and Romantic visions of harmony. The